Outlander Book Club: Book 2, Chapter 41 breakdown

Foreshadowing in the Outlander chapter

There isn’t too much in the way of foreshadowing in the chapter. There’s that sense of hope that history can be changed, but something that stands out for me is the difference between Maisri and Claire.

Maisri is a Seer. She sees one thing and is able to figure out the best way to prevent that one thing from happening. It’s a relatively small thing, too. In her explanation, she saved one man’s son from drowning in a storm and the way to do it was to put a hole in the son’s boat.

Claire is looking to do something much bigger. She wants to change the course of history for hundreds of thousands of people. And this isn’t based on one vision but on the history books. Claire doesn’t know what to change. While there’s hope, I think reading between it all, there’s foreshadowing that history on such a large scale simply can’t be changed, but there’s nothing wrong with saving the odd person here and there.

The ending has the biggest moment that pushes us into the next chapters. The Lallybroch men never made it home. Presumably (we know by reading forward a little) the deserting men were caught. Will they all be viewed as traitors to Charles?

There’s also foreshadowing that Jamie will not try to win Culloden. He’ll go back to trying to prevent it from happening at all.

There is an element of foreshadowing when it comes to Claire’s description of Maisri. The Seer is described as a woman with black hair streaked with white. Later in the books, Claire learns she’ll come into her full powers when her hair turns white. Is this an element of foreshadowing that people with magic will gain white hair early and end up with a full head of white?

Adapting the Dragonfly in Amber chapter for the show

This chapter was used, but only briefly. The biggest focus was on Young Simon being the one to join the cause. However, that wasn’t quite with Lord Lovat’s full permission. In the show, Lord Lovat only agreed to a small contingency and mostly farmers. The good fighters would stay behind. That’s not the case in the book.

Another part of the chapter adapted was the use of Maisri. Claire realizes that Lord Lovat is superstitious. She tries to use that by giving Lord Lovat a vision, but it fails. The entire illness storyline is avoided.

The lack of the illness storyline will be due to time. The show moved this part of the storyline forward and brought Colum MacKenzie into it. Two storylines were combined into one because they were both important, but it means certain elements of those storylines were skipped over to only fit in the most important details.

What did you notice while reading Outlander Book 2, Chapter 41? Share in the comments below.

Like Claire and Jamie on Facebook for the latest Outlander Book Club breakdowns.